Image, Figure, and Multimedia Integrity

8.1 Purpose and Scope

  • This policy safeguards the accuracy of all visual and audiovisual materials in published content: scientific images, charts, diagrams, artwork, audio, video, animations, and interactive media. It applies to authors, editors, reviewers, and production staff across all journals we publish.

8.2 First Principles

  • Show the data, do not reshape the truth. Visual changes must never mislead or alter scientific meaning.
  • Transparency by default. Any enhancement or composition must be disclosed in the figure legend or Methods.
  • Verifiability. Originals and processing steps must be available for editorial inspection upon request.

8.3 Acceptable Global Adjustments (with disclosure)

  • Uniform, non-selective adjustments are allowed if they do not hide, introduce, or exaggerate features:
  • Brightness, contrast, and gamma applied to the entire image.
  • Uniform white balance, exposure, or color-space conversions.
  • Linear cropping that does not remove essential context (e.g., scale bars, controls).
  • Disclosure: “Global brightness/contrast adjustments applied; no pixel-level alterations.”

8.4 Prohibited Manipulations

  • Selective enhancement, suppression, or removal of features (e.g., erasing bands, adding spots, cloning backgrounds).
  • Splicing lanes or fields without clear demarcation lines and labeling.
  • Nonlinear intensity adjustments that distort relative differences without disclosure.
  • Artificial smoothing/denoising that removes meaningful signal or artifacts critical for interpretation.
  • AI-based inpainting or generative fills that fabricate data elements.
  • Violations may trigger rejection, correction, expression of concern, or retraction.

8.5 Composites and Splices (Permitted with strict labeling)

  • Show borders between panels/lanes/fields with clear separating lines.
  • Label each segment (e.g., “lane 1–4 from gel A; lane 5–7 from gel B”).
  • Provide acquisition dates/instruments if multiple sessions were combined.
  • State any re-ordering of lanes or fields.

8.6 Source Data and Provenance

  • For every figure derived from empirical data, authors must retain and, on request, provide:
  • Raw, unprocessed image files (native formats, e.g., .lif, .czi, .nd2; DICOM for radiology).
  • Acquisition metadata (instrument, objective, numerical aperture, voxel size/pixel scale, exposure, filters).
  • Processing logs or stepwise description sufficient to reproduce the final figure.
  • Minimum retention: consistent with field norms and legal/ethical requirements.

8.7 Scale, Units, and Calibration

  • Include scale bars or explicit magnification and units.
  • Do not rely on relative magnification descriptions alone.
  • Report calibration methods for imaging systems and measurement devices.

8.8 Color, False Color, and Perceptual Integrity

  • Use color maps that preserve ordinal/interval relationships; avoid misleading palettes that create false boundaries.
  • Identify false-color or pseudocolor images and specify channel mapping.
  • Multi-channel images must state dyes/fluorophores, emission/ excitation settings, and channel order.

8.9 Specific Modalities — Minimum Standards

  • Gels/Blots: Show full-length blots or provide uncropped source images as supplements; mark reused lanes; avoid background obliteration.
  • Microscopy: Report optical setup, z-stacks, deconvolution, projection type; disclose stitching/tiling.
  • Flow Cytometry: Provide gating strategy, compensation, controls, event counts; show axis scales consistently.
  • Spectra/Chromatograms: Include axis units, baselines, smoothing parameters; avoid baseline subtraction without disclosure.
  • Radiology/Clinical: Anonymize DICOM headers; disclose window/level settings if diagnostically relevant.
  • Maps/Geospatial: Name coordinate reference systems, data sources, and spatial resolution; indicate any generalization or masking for privacy.

8.10 Charts and Statistical Graphics

  • Axes must have units, scales, and zero baselines where appropriate.
  • Avoid truncated axes that distort effect size; if truncation is necessary, indicate clearly.
  • Show individual data points or distribution summaries (e.g., box/violin plots) whenever feasible; avoid deceptive 3D embellishments.
  • Report sample sizes (n) and measures of dispersion (SD/SE/CI) in legends or captions.

8.11 Figure Assembly and Layout

  • Panels labeled consistently (A, B, C…); legends explain each panel.
  • Do not duplicate the same image in multiple panels to represent different conditions.
  • Avoid excessive compression artifacts; submit publication-quality resolution (typically ≥300 dpi for raster images at final size).

8.12 Audio, Video, and Animation

  • State frame rate, resolution, and any edits (speed changes, cuts, stabilization).
  • Do not add or remove sounds or visual events that change interpretation.
  • Provide closed captions or transcripts when feasible; anonymize voices and faces where required.

8.13 Accessibility of Visuals

  • Provide alt text or concise, descriptive captions that convey the scientific message.
  • Ensure sufficient contrast ratios for text and critical features.
  • Avoid color-only encodings; use patterns or markers to differentiate series.

8.14 Image Integrity Screening (Publisher)

  • Editorial staff may use automated tools to identify:
  • Duplications, splices, contrast anomalies, and cloning artifacts.
  • Inconsistent noise patterns or compression signatures.
  • Findings trigger human expert review; automated flags never determine outcomes alone.

8.15 Disclosure Templates (for authors)

  • Image Processing Statement: “Only uniform, global adjustments (brightness/contrast) were applied. No selective editing or data removal occurred. Composite boundaries are marked; full-length blots provided in Supplementary Figures S1–S3.”
  • Figure Legend Minimums: source of data; acquisition instrument/settings; units/scale; n per group; statistical tests; definitions of symbols and error bars.

8.16 Third-Party and Stock Visuals

  • Scientific illustrations or icons must not imply empirical measurements.
  • Obtain and document licenses/permissions.
  • Acknowledge illustrators/designers; avoid misleading photorealistic renderings for hypothetical mechanisms.

8.17 Privacy and Identifiability

  • Remove direct identifiers from clinical images or obtain explicit consent for publication.
  • For sensitive locations (e.g., endangered species habitats, refugee settlements), consider obfuscation or coordinate generalization and state the method.

8.18 Non-Compliance and Remedial Actions

  • Pre-publication: Request originals, revisions, or withdraw the manuscript.
  • Post-publication: Publish corrections, image replacements with clear notes, expressions of concern, or retractions if conclusions are undermined.
  • Notify institutions/funders when appropriate; apply submission bans for repeated or egregious violations.