9.1 Purpose and Scope
- This section defines how we run peer review across all journals we publish. It covers editor responsibilities, reviewer selection and conduct, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, decision criteria, revisions, appeals, special issues, and post-publication dialogue. The goal is rigorous, fair, and timely assessment that protects the scholarly record.
9.2 Peer-Review Models (Declared per Journal)
Each journal publicly states its model; options we support:
- Double-anonymized (authors and reviewers blinded).
- Single-anonymized (reviewers blinded; editors know identities).
- Open review (identities and/or reports public).
- Transparent review (anonymous reports published with the article).
- Registered Reports (peer review of study design before results).
- Any departures from a journal’s default model must be disclosed to authors in advance.
9.3 Editorial Roles and Safeguards
- Handling editor authority: Assigned editors—free of conflicts—oversee peer review and make recommendations/decisions under the journal’s policies.
- Independence: Business, marketing, and sponsors have no role in editorial decisions.
- Editor-authored submissions: Processed by an independent editor via a firewalled workflow; the author-editor has no system access to discussions or reviewer identities.
- Documentation: Key actions (assignment, invitations, decisions) are logged for audit.
9.4 Manuscript Screening (Pre-Review)
Every submission is checked for:
- Scope and reporting fit (see Sections 5–8).
- Ethics: IRB/animal approvals, trial registration, permits, DURC/biosafety where relevant.
- Integrity: plagiarism/duplicate checks, figure screening, and basic statistical/ methods sanity checks.
- Editors may desk-reject with constructive reasons when manuscripts clearly do not meet standards.
9.5 Reviewer Selection
- Expertise: Reviewers are chosen for subject, methodological, and statistical expertise; diversity of perspectives is encouraged.
- Conflicts: We avoid reviewers with recent collaboration, shared affiliations or grants, personal relationships, or direct competition. Declared COIs are logged; conflicted reviewers are not used.
- Availability and timeliness: Invitations specify deadlines and expectations.
- Identity verification: We take steps to validate reviewer identities and email domains; suspicious nominations are independently verified.
9.6 Co-Reviewing and Mentored Review
- Invited reviewers may involve a named junior colleague for training only with prior editor approval and with full confidentiality and COI checks. The invited reviewer remains responsible for the report. Co-reviewer names are shared with the editor and, in open/transparent models, acknowledged with consent.
9.7 Reviewer Responsibilities and Conduct
Reviewers agree to:
- Confidentiality: Do not share or reuse manuscript content; delete files after review.
- Objectivity and civility: Critique methods and evidence, not people; avoid derogatory language.
- Substantiation: Support critiques with citations or concrete methodological rationale.
- No use of unpublished information for personal benefit.
- AI tools: Follow Section 3; do not upload confidential content to external tools lacking approved safeguards; the review must reflect the reviewer’s own judgment.
- Timeliness: Deliver reports on time or decline promptly.
9.8 Reviewer Report Content (Minimums)
- Summary of key findings and claims.
- Methodological evaluation (design, analysis, statistics, reproducibility).
- Ethics and transparency checks (approvals, consent, data/code availability, image integrity).
- Specific, actionable recommendations for improvement.
- Confidential note to editor (optional) separate from comments to authors.
9.9 Decision Criteria and Taxonomy
Decisions are grounded in methodological rigor, clarity, ethics compliance, and contribution to the field. Standard decisions:
- Reject (desk or after review).
- Major revision.
- Minor revision.
- Accept.
Editors provide clear rationales; where reviewer advice diverges, editors synthesize the case and justify the decision.
9.10 Revision Process
- Authors must include a point-by-point response mapping revisions to reviewer/editor comments, with tracked-changes or marked-up files.
- Substantive methodological changes require updated analyses and, when needed, additional review or statistical assessment.
- New experiments should be justified by their necessity to address validity, not by novelty alone.
9.11 Appeals and Complaints (Process)
- Appeals must provide a concise, evidence-based rebuttal addressing specific points of error or misunderstanding; an independent editor reviews the appeal.
- Complaints about conduct, bias, or process are acknowledged within set timelines and handled under our conflict and integrity procedures. Frivolous or repetitive appeals may be declined with reasons.
9.12 Special Issues, Guest Editors, and Collections
- Guest editors sign COI and independence statements and follow the same reviewer-selection standards.
- The journal’s Editor-in-Chief or a designate provides oversight, including random audits of reviewer choices and decisions.
- Red flags (citation cartels, anomalous acceptance patterns, paper-mill indicators) trigger intervention, up to cancellation of submissions or re-review.
9.13 Statistical and Methods Review
- For complex or high-stakes analyses, editors may seek specialist review (statistics, data science, qualitative methods, ethics).
- Where appropriate, authors provide analysis code, data samples, and image originals to enable verification.
9.14 Anonymity, Transparency, and Credit
- The default anonymity follows the journal’s model.
- With consent and where policy allows, we may publish review reports, decision letters, and author rebuttals.
- We can issue reviewer recognition (certificates, ORCID credit) without compromising confidentiality when anonymity is required.
9.15 Transfer and Portable Peer Review
- With author consent, editors may transfer manuscripts (with reviews) to another journal within our portfolio when the work is sound but a better scope fit exists.
- We may accept portable peer review reports from trusted partners; transferred reports are verified for integrity and reviewed for fit.
9.16 Handling Suspected Misconduct During Review
- Signals (plagiarism, fabricated data, image manipulation, identity fraud, peer-review manipulation) prompt editorial inquiry and, if needed, contact with institutions or funders.
- Editorial actions prioritize safeguarding the record and may include hold, reject, or post-publication measures per our integrity policy.
9.17 Timelines and Communication
- Journals display typical time to first decision and time to publication with date ranges and methods.
- Authors receive status updates at key stages (sent to review, reviews received, decision pending).
- Significant delays are communicated with revised estimates or alternative handling (e.g., reassignment).
9.18 Confidentiality Boundaries
- Identities of reviewers are kept confidential unless an open/transparent model or explicit consent applies.
- Manuscript content is confidential; it must not be shared outside the editorial process or used for competitive advantage.
9.19 Editorial Research Use of Manuscripts
- Unpublished submissions are not used by editors or reviewers for their own research without written author permission and after publication or formal withdrawal.
9.20 Record-Keeping and Audit
- Systems retain invitation logs, COI statements, decision letters, and timelines for a defined retention period.
- Random audits assess adherence to policy (e.g., conflicts management, reviewer diversity, turnaround). Findings inform process improvement.
9.21 Sanctions for Reviewer or Editor Misconduct
- Possible actions include removal from the reviewer pool or editorial board, notification to institutions, and—where appropriate—public notes of correction to maintain trust in the process.
9.22 Post-Publication Dialogue
- We welcome comments, letters, and scholarly rebuttals. Substantive critiques are evaluated fairly and may lead to corrections or other actions. Civility and evidence standards apply.
9.23 Use of Technology in Editorial Work
- Tools for plagiarism detection, image integrity screening, reference checking, and workflow support may be employed, with human editorial judgment making final decisions (see Section 3 on AI use).
9.24 Accessibility and Inclusion in Peer Review
- Editors strive for inclusive reviewer pools across geography, gender, career stage, and institution type.
- Reasonable accommodations are provided for reviewers or authors with accessibility needs (extended deadlines, accessible document formats).
9.25 Final Acceptance to Production Handoff
- Before acceptance, editors verify ethics statements, COI/Funding statements, reporting checklists, DAS/Code availability, and image/source-data readiness.
- Accepted manuscripts proceed to production with clear metadata, licensing, and any transparency notes (e.g., published peer-review files) attached.