Misconduct, Corrections, and Retractions

10.1 Purpose and Scope

  • This policy protects the integrity of the scholarly record by defining research and publication misconduct, our investigation procedures, and the editorial actions we may take before or after publication. It applies to authors, editors, reviewers, and all publisher staff across our journals.

10.2 Definitions (Non-Exhaustive)

  • Fabrication: Making up data, results, images, or citations.
  • Falsification: Manipulating data, images, methods, or materials such that the research is misrepresented.
  • Plagiarism: Presenting another’s work, ideas, or words without proper credit; includes self-plagiarism/duplicate publication when prior work is reused without disclosure.
  • Image manipulation: Selective enhancement, splicing, cloning, or inpainting that changes meaning without disclosure (see Section 8).
  • Authorship misconduct: Ghost, guest/gift, or purchased authorship; forged approvals; undisclosed professional writers.
  • Peer-review manipulation: Fake reviewer identities, reviewer suggestion fraud, coercive citation, or undisclosed use of AI tools to write reviews.
  • Citation manipulation: Inappropriate self-citation or citation cartels intended to game metrics.
  • Paper mill activity: Systematic production or sale of fabricated or manipulated manuscripts or authorship slots.
  • Ethics non-compliance: Absent or misrepresented IRB/IACUC approvals, consent, permits, trial registration, or data-protection safeguards.
  • Undeclared conflicts of interest: Material financial or non-financial interests not disclosed at submission or publication.

10.3 Principles for Handling Concerns

  • Fair process: We evaluate allegations objectively, without presumption of guilt.
  • Proportionality: Actions match the severity and impact on the record.
  • Documented reasoning: We keep internal decision records and provide clear public notices when the record changes.
  • Independence: Business and sponsorship do not influence integrity decisions.
  • Timeliness: We acknowledge credible reports promptly and aim to conclude investigations within reasonable, stated timelines.

10.4 How Concerns May Arise

  • Editorial checks (plagiarism, figure screening, statistical sanity checks).
  • Reviewer, reader, or whistleblower reports (anonymous reports accepted with sufficient detail).
  • Post-publication commentary or replication attempts.
  • Notifications from institutions, funders, or other journals.

10.5 Intake and Triage

  • Acknowledge receipt to the reporter (when contactable).
  • Preliminary review by an integrity editor to assess scope, plausibility, and risk.
  • Hold editorial processing when necessary (e.g., suspend peer review or acceptance).
  • Conflict check and assignment to a handling editor uninvolved with the work.

10.6 Evidence Gathering

  • Request original data, images, code, protocols, and approvals from authors.
  • Conduct similarity checks and image forensics; compare figures across versions and venues.
  • Where relevant, contact institutions, funders, ethics committees, or data repositories for verification.
  • Maintain the chain of custody for files and logs used in decisions.

10.7 Author Engagement

  • Share the specific concerns with the corresponding author (and, where appropriate, all authors).
  • Provide a response window proportionate to the case; extensions considered with justification.
  • Require author-signed statements for factual clarifications; disagreements are documented.

10.8 Possible Outcomes (Pre-Publication)

  • Proceed after clarification or minor correction.
  • Revise with required changes (e.g., corrected figures, fuller disclosures).
  • Reject for integrity reasons, with reasons recorded.
  • Refer to institutions or funders for formal investigation when warranted.

10.9 Possible Outcomes (Post-Publication)

  • Editor’s Note / Addendum: Minor clarifications that do not alter conclusions.
  • Correction (Erratum/Corrigendum): Fixes factual or production errors that affect but do not invalidate findings.
  • Author Correction vs. Publisher Correction: Labeled accordingly; both link bidirectionally to the Version of Record.
  • Expression of Concern (EoC): Public notice when serious doubts exist but an investigation is ongoing or evidence is inconclusive.
  • Retraction: Public notice that the article’s findings are unreliable due to misconduct or honest error (e.g., pervasive analytical flaws).
  • Retraction and Replacement: In rare cases of honest error where corrected results are valid and independently verified, a replacement article may be issued with full provenance.
  • Withdrawal (Early/Online First): For items not yet assigned to an issue when fundamental issues are identified.
  • Removal (Exceptional): Used only for legal reasons (e.g., court orders, severe defamation, privacy violations, or serious public health risk). A tombstone notice remains with reasons.

10.10 Content of Public Notices

  • All public notices (corrections, EoCs, retractions, removals) are:
  • Openly accessible and permanently linked to the affected article (and vice versa).
  • Transparent: State who issues the notice, the reasons, which parts are affected, and whether conclusions are impacted.
  • Traceable: Include dates, DOIs, and version history.
  • Neutral in tone: Fact-focused, avoiding defamatory language.

10.11 Retraction Practice Details

  • Who retracts: Preferably all authors; if not feasible or if authors disagree, the editor/publisher may retract to protect the record.
  • Availability: The original article remains online with a clear watermark or header stating “Retracted,” preserving bibliographic metadata.
  • Indexing: We notify indexing services and repositories; metadata reflects the retracted status.
  • Authorship and responsibility: Notices indicate whether misconduct was determined and, if known, by whom (without unnecessary personal data).
  • Citations: We discourage uncritical citation of retracted work and encourage citing the retraction notice when discussing the case.

10.12 Paper Mills, Fraud Rings, and Systemic Irregularities

  • Use anomaly detection (e.g., unusual author networks, stock images, identical phrases, reference patterns).
  • Apply portfolio-wide checks and, where needed, audits of special issues and guest-edited collections.
  • Suspend pipelines and invalidate compromised peer review; re-review by independent experts.
  • Coordinate with other journals and institutions where appropriate.

10.13 Peer-Review Integrity

  • Validate reviewer identities and contact details; scrutinize author-nominated reviewers.
  • Prohibit reviewers from delegating without prior approval (see Section 9).
  • Address coercive citation or unprofessional conduct with warnings, removal from reviewer pools, or institutional notification.

10.14 Undeclared or Disputed Conflicts of Interest

  • Publish addenda or corrections to disclose previously omitted conflicts when material.
  • If nondisclosure likely biased design, analysis, or interpretation, escalate to EoC or retraction.

10.15 Appeals of Integrity Decisions

  • Authors may appeal by submitting new evidence or pointing to procedural error.
  • Appeals are reviewed by an independent editor or committee not involved in the original decision.
  • Repeated or unsupported appeals may be declined with reasons recorded.

10.16 Record-Keeping and Retention

  • Retain integrity-related correspondence, reports, and evidence for a defined period consistent with legal and ethical requirements.
  • Maintain an internal register of corrections, EoCs, retractions, and removals for audit and transparency.

10.17 Communication and Confidentiality

  • We protect the identity of whistleblowers where lawful and feasible.
  • We may share necessary information with institutions, funders, or regulators to facilitate investigations, observing privacy and due process.

10.18 Sanctions

  • For confirmed misconduct: rejection of current submissions, submission bans for a defined period, editorial board removal, reviewer debarment, and institutional notification.
  • For guest editors: removal from roles, annulment of compromised issues, and public editorial notes where appropriate.

10.19 Legal and Ethical Considerations

  • Integrity actions observe applicable laws (defamation, privacy, data protection, export controls).
  • We avoid statements of fault beyond the evidence; when legal constraints limit disclosure, we state that details are withheld for legal reasons.

10.20 Continuous Improvement

  • We periodically review and update procedures in light of community standards, case analyses, and stakeholder feedback.
  • Policy pages display version histories and last-updated dates; substantive changes are communicated across journal sites.