Preprints, Post-Publication Review & Versioning

11.1 Purpose and Scope

  • This section defines our publisher-wide policies on preprints, community discussion after publication, and version control for scholarly works. It applies to all journals we publish and to all article types unless a journal explicitly states a narrower policy.

11.2 Preprint-Friendly Policy

  • Not prior publication. Posting a manuscript to a recognized preprint server does not count as prior publication and will not prejudice editorial assessment.
  • Allowed servers. Authors may post to discipline-appropriate, non-commercial or community servers (e.g., arXiv, bioRxiv/medRxiv, SocArXiv, EarthArXiv, OSF Preprints, institutional repositories).
  • What may be posted. The author’s original manuscript (submitted version) or accepted manuscript (post-peer-review, pre-typesetting) may be posted per journal-specific license terms (see Section 12).
  • Embargoes. We do not require preprint embargoes. If a journal participates in media embargo programs, authors should coordinate press releases to avoid confusion (see 11.12).

11.3 Disclosure at Submission

Authors must:

  • Indicate the preprint DOI/URL at submission.
  • Disclose any public commentary or reviews the preprint has received.
  • Ensure that the preprint metadata lists the current submission status where the server supports this.

11.4 Preprint Citation and Priority

  • Citing preprints. Preprints are citable research objects. Cite them like articles, including version/date and persistent identifier.
  • Priority claims. Preprint timestamps establish priority of discovery; publication in our journals establishes the version of record (VoR).

11.5 Screening & Ethics for Preprinted Work

  • All ethical and integrity requirements apply regardless of preprint status (Sections 5–10).
  • For high-risk topics (e.g., clinical claims, dual-use), editors may request clarifications about the preprint’s dissemination and any public impacts already observed.

11.6 Linking Preprints to the Version of Record

  • On publication, authors should update the preprint record to link to the VoR DOI and include the recommended citation.
  • Where servers support “published” badges or automatic back-linking, we facilitate this.
  • If the accepted manuscript is deposited, include the VoR link and license notice required by the journal.

11.7 Accepted Manuscripts (AAMs) and Self-Archiving

  • Authors may deposit the AAM in repositories permitted by the journal’s license (Section 12), with clear labeling: “Author accepted manuscript; not the final typeset version.”
  • Include the VoR DOI upon publication and any required publisher statement.

11.8 Community Review and Overlay Models

  • We welcome post-publication peer commentary, overlays, and independent replications that engage constructively with published work.
  • Journals may pilot overlay review (linking external reviews to VoR). External reviews must disclose identities or follow the host’s transparency standards and adhere to our conduct policy (11.13).

11.9 Post-Publication Comments, Letters, and Replies

  • Channels. We accept formal Letters to the Editor, moderated comments, or registered scholarly replies.
  • Standards. Submissions must be evidence-based, specific, civil, and concise. Personal attacks and unsubstantiated claims are rejected.
  • Timelines. Authors of the target article are invited to reply; both pieces may be peer-reviewed proportionally to claims made.
  • Archiving. Accepted letters/replies receive DOIs and are permanently linked to the VoR.

11.10 Corrections Triggered by Post-Publication Review

  • Substantive, credible issues raised in public forums or letters are investigated under Section 10.
  • Outcomes include corrections, editor’s notes, expressions of concern, or retractions, with public, permanent notices.

11.11 Versioning Policy (All Article Types)

  • Each article has exactly one Version of Record (VoR) with a DOI.
  • Earlier public versions (preprint, AAM) should link forward to the VoR; later updates are handled through formal notices (corrections/addenda) or retraction and replacement where appropriate.
  • For living resources (e.g., datasets, software), see Section 7 for versioned identifiers and changelogs.

11.12 Media, Press, and Embargoes

  • Authors may discuss preprints with the media using careful, non-promotional language that reflects uncertainty.
  • If a journal or study is under an embargo, coordinate press activity with the editorial office. Embargoes do not restrict preprint posting, but press releases should avoid overstating unreviewed findings.

11.13 Community Conduct & Moderation

  • Public discussion spaces hosted by the publisher are moderated for civility, relevance, and privacy compliance.
  • Prohibited: harassment, doxxing, disclosure of confidential peer-review content, or discriminatory language.
  • Moderation actions range from content removal to account suspension; serious cases may be escalated under Section 10.

11.14 Transparency of Review Histories

  • Journals may offer transparent peer review: publishing anonymized review reports, decision letters, and author rebuttals alongside the VoR with author/reviewer consent.
  • Metadata will indicate whether transparency applies and which documents are included.

11.15 Open Annotation and Third-Party Platforms

  • We enable or respect standards-based annotation (e.g., via compatible web annotation services) where feasible.
  • Authors and readers should distinguish speculation from evidence; editors may issue notes when public annotations reveal substantive concerns.

11.16 Simultaneous Submissions & Duplicate Records

  • Preprints are not simultaneous submissions. Submitting the same manuscript to multiple journals concurrently is prohibited unless a coordinated multi-journal agreement exists.
  • Duplicate postings of near-identical content across servers should be avoided; if necessary, cross-link and explain differences.

11.17 Data, Code, and Materials Alignment

  • When a preprint advertises open data/code, the published article must include functioning links and the same or improved availability unless legal/ethical constraints intervene. Any restriction changes must be explained in the VoR (see Section 7).

11.18 Author Name and Metadata Consistency

  • Keep author names, ORCID iDs, titles, and abstracts consistent across preprint, AAM, and VoR where possible. If changes are needed (e.g., clarifications, name updates), propagate updates and link all versions clearly.

11.19 Rapid Responses During Public Health or Safety Events

  • For urgent topics, editors may expedite clarifications or risk-mitigated updates and coordinate with repositories to highlight changes. Speed never overrides accuracy, ethics, or safety.

11.20 Record-Keeping and Discoverability

  • Preprint DOIs/URLs and post-publication discussion items are captured in article metadata to improve indexing and discovery.
  • We encourage authors to maintain current links and to notify editorial offices of major preprint revisions that materially affect interpretation.