Special Issues & Guest Editing

18.1 Purpose and Scope

  • This policy governs special issues, thematic collections, and guest-edited supplements across our portfolio. It ensures topic relevance, rigorous peer review, conflict-of-interest (COI) management, and editorial independence from sponsors or commercial interests.

18.2 When We Launch a Special Issue

  • Scholarly need: Clear rationale (emerging area, methods consolidation, replication initiative).
  • Fit to journal scope: The host journal confirms alignment and capacity.
  • Diversity of voices: Aim for geographic, institutional, career-stage, and methodological diversity in both guest editors and contributors.
  • Feasibility: Timeline, expected submissions, reviewer availability, and production capacity are documented.

18.3 Guest Editor Eligibility & Roles

  • Eligibility: Recognized expertise and a track record of rigorous, ethical scholarship; no recent sanctions for research-integrity violations.
  • Roles: Draft the Call for Papers (CFP), advise on scope, nominate reviewers, handle editorial decisions under oversight (18.6), and uphold all portfolio policies.
  • Training: Guest editors receive a short onboarding covering peer-review integrity, COI, AI use in editorial work, and anomaly detection.

18.4 Conflicts of Interest (Guest Editors & Team)

  • Mandatory disclosures: Financial and non-financial interests for the past 3 years; institutional ties; active collaborations with prospective authors.
  • Recusal: Guest editors must not handle manuscripts from current/ recent collaborators, same departments, family/close relationships, or direct competitors.
  • Editor-authored submissions: If guest editors submit, their papers are managed by an independent handling editor outside the guest team, with firewalled access.

18.5 Call for Papers (CFP) Requirements

Every CFP must state:

  • Aims & scope (clear inclusion/exclusion criteria).
  • Article types invited and reporting standards.
  • Ethics & transparency expectations.
  • Submission window and deadlines, including the timezone.
  • Fees/waivers (if any) with links.
  • COI & funding disclosures required from authors.
  • Preprint policy and data/code availability.
  • Editorial independence and review model used.

18.6 Oversight & Governance

  • Accountable Editor-in-Chief (EIC): Assigns an in-house Oversight Editor who monitors adherence to policy, conducts spot checks, and approves edge cases.
  • Decision authority: Guest editors recommend; the journal’s EIC (or delegate) makes or confirms final decisions where policy requires.
  • Audit trail: System logs retain assignments, COI decisions, reviewer selections, and rationales.

18.7 Reviewer Selection & Quality Control

  • Standards identical to regular issues: At least two independent expert reviews (unless article type justifies fewer with rationale).
  • No sponsor influence: Sponsors (if any) cannot suggest or approve reviewers.
  • Diversity of expertise: Statistical/methodological review used when warranted.
  • Co-reviewing: Allowed with prior approval and named junior co-reviewers.

18.8 Integrity Safeguards & Anomaly Detection

We screen for:

  • Unusual authorship networks or repeated affiliations.
  • Citation cartels, coercive citation, and abnormal reference patterns.
  • Paper-mill signals (template phrasing, stock images, manipulated figures).
  • Compressed timelines with insufficient review.
  • Flagged manuscripts receive independent checks; the Oversight Editor may reassign editors, add reviews, or halt the collection.

18.9 Sponsored Supplements (If Applicable)

  • Labeling: Sponsor name and role displayed on the collection page and article landing pages.
  • Independence: Sponsor has no role in editorial decisions or reviewer choice.
  • Standards: Same peer-review and ethics policies as regular issues; deviations (if any) are explicitly documented.
  • Transparency: Funding statements and data access roles are published on each article.

18.10 Timeline Management

  • Milestones: CFP launch, submission deadline, first-decision target, revision window(s), final acceptance, and publication date range.
  • Scope creep: Major changes to aims or deadlines require public notice on the CFP page.
  • Throughput: If backlog threatens quality, we cap acceptances or extend timelines rather than compress review.

18.11 Acceptance Rates & Balance

  • Special-issue acceptance rates are monitored and reported internally; outliers trigger review by the Oversight Editor.
  • Collections must not crowd out regular submissions; journals maintain a healthy topic and author diversity.

18.12 Ethics & Compliance Checks

Before acceptance, editors verify:

  • IRB/IACUC/permits/registration.
  • Reporting checklists.
  • DAS/Code/Materials statements.
  • Image integrity and figure provenance.
  • COI/Funding statements for authors and guest editors.

18.13 Handling Misconduct or Process Failures

  • During review: Pause or reassign; add independent reviews; escalate to integrity procedures.
  • After publication: Corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions follow standard policy; in severe cases we may invalidate a compromised special issue and re-evaluate included articles.

18.14 Communication & Branding

  • Special issues are clearly branded with editors’ names and affiliations.
  • No misleading claims (indexing, impact metrics, speed).
  • All marketing materials link to the policy page and the CFP.

18.15 Data & Metadata

  • The collection page lists guest editors, aims, CFP link, and articles with DOIs.
  • Metadata includes a collection identifier for discovery; articles are cross-linked to the collection and main journal issue.

18.16 Accessibility & Inclusion

  • CFPs and collection pages follow Section 14 standards (WCAG 2.2 AA).
  • We encourage participation from underrepresented groups and provide reasonable accommodations (e.g., deadline flexibility for accessibility needs).

18.17 Compensation and Gifts

  • Honoraria (if offered) are transparent and not contingent on acceptance counts.
  • No gifts or hospitality beyond de minimis value; anything more is declined to protect independence.

18.18 Post-Publication Curation

  • Collections may add invited perspectives, registered replies, or curated replications.
  • Updates and corrigenda are linked bidirectionally; the collection page shows a change log.

18.19 Closure & Evaluation

  • After completion, the Oversight Editor issues a brief internal report (adherence to policy, timelines, anomaly findings, acceptance rate, waiver utilization).
  • Lessons learned inform future CFP templates and training.

18.20 Templates (for Immediate Use)

 

  • 18.20.1 Guest Editor COI Declaration (excerpt)
    • “I, [Name], declare the following interests for the past 36 months: [financial/non-financial]. I will recuse myself from manuscripts where a reasonable reader would perceive a conflict. I will not handle manuscripts from current or recent collaborators, same departments, family/close relationships, or direct competitors.”
  • 18.20.2 CFP Boilerplate (excerpt)
    • “Call for Papers — [Special Issue Title]
    • We invite original research, methods, reviews, and registered reports on [scope]. Submissions must follow journal policies on ethics, reporting standards, data/code availability, image integrity, and peer review. Deadline: [Date, Timezone]. Preprints welcome. Waiver information: [link].”