Appeals, Complaints, and Whistleblowing

21.1 Purpose and Scope

  • This section sets out how authors, reviewers, readers, editors, and staff can appeal editorial decisions, complain about process or conduct, and report integrity concerns (whistleblowing) across our portfolio. It covers intake, timelines, confidentiality, standards of review, outcomes, escalation, and records.

21.2 Definitions

  • Appeal: A request from an author to reconsider an editorial decision, citing factual error, methodological misunderstanding, or material new evidence.
  • Complaint: An allegation of procedural unfairness, bias, delay, accessibility failure, fee/waiver handling issues, or unprofessional behavior not tied to scientific integrity.
  • Whistleblowing (Integrity Report): A good-faith report that research may be unreliable or that there is misconduct (fabrication/falsification/plagiarism, image manipulation, undisclosed COI, peer-review manipulation), whether pre- or post-publication.

21.3 Principles

  • Fair, timely, documented. Each case is acknowledged, logged, and handled against published timelines.
  • Independence. Decision reviewers are free of relevant conflicts and separate from commercial functions.
  • Proportionality. Responses match the risk and impact.
  • Non-retaliation. Reporters and participants in good faith are protected from retaliation.
  • Privacy by default. We disclose the minimum necessary information and respect legal constraints.

21.4 How to Contact Us

  • Appeals (authors): Use the Appeal a Decision form linked from the decision letter or journal site.
  • Complaints (process/conduct): Use the Editorial Process Complaint form or the publisher contact listed on each journal’s page.
  • Whistleblowing (integrity): Use the Research Integrity Report channel (anonymous submissions accepted if specific).
  • Alternate channels (accessibility email, privacy request portal) route to the same tracking system.

21.5 What to Include

  • Appeals: DOI/manuscript ID, decision letter date, precise points of error or misunderstanding (with citations/analyses), and any new evidence (e.g., additional data, reanalysis).
  • Complaints: Event description, dates, involved roles (if known), desired remedy, and any supporting material.
  • Integrity reports: Specific claim(s), affected figure/table/section, comparison sources, and any files evidencing the concern (e.g., raw images).

21.6 Timelines (Targets)

  • Acknowledgment: within 5 business days.
  • Appeal initial assessment: within 15 business days.
  • Complaint initial assessment: within 15 business days.
  • Integrity triage: within 10 business days (faster for high-risk cases).
  • Complex cases may require more time; we will provide updates and revised targets.

21.7 Eligibility and Limits

  • Only authors of record may appeal editorial decisions.
  • Multiple or serial appeals must present new arguments or evidence; otherwise they may be declined with reasons.
  • Complaints may be filed by any participant (author/reviewer/editor/reader) with standing. Anonymous integrity reports are considered when sufficiently detailed.

21.8 Standards of Review (Appeals)

  • An appeal may be upheld when any of the following apply:
  • Material error in interpreting the data, methods, or literature.
  • Procedural irregularity (e.g., conflict not managed, key review omitted).
  • New evidence that could reasonably change the decision.
  • Editorial “difference of opinion” without error is insufficient for reversal.

21.9 How Appeals Are Handled

  • Assigned to an independent editor (not involved in the original decision) or an Appeals Committee for complex cases.
  • The independent editor may seek external advice (e.g., statistical review) and, where appropriate, de-identify materials.
  • Outcomes:
    • Uphold original decision (with reasons).
    • Invite revision and re-review (specifying issues to address).
    • Overturn and accept (rare; requires strong justification).
    • A single appeal review is final at the publisher level unless new facts emerge.

21.10 Complaints About Process or Conduct

  • Covers delays, communication failures, accessibility barriers, tone or civility, editorial bias, fee/waiver handling, or advertising adjacency concerns.
  • Assessment: Fact-finding via logs, correspondence, and interviews as needed.
  • Outcomes: Apology and remedial action (e.g., expedite handling, assign a new editor), training/coaching, or policy correction.
  • Exclusions: Scientific content disputes are routed to appeals; allegations of misconduct move to integrity procedures.

21.11 Whistleblowing & Integrity Intake

  • Risk triage: Categorize by severity (e.g., safety/clinical impact, dual-use risk, widespread error).
  • Preserve evidence: Secure files, system logs, and versions; halt editorial progression if needed.
  • Conflict check: Assign an Integrity Editor uninvolved with the work.

21.12 Confidentiality & Anonymity

  • We protect reporter identity where feasible and lawful. Anonymous reports are considered on merit; limited disclosure may be required to verify facts.
  • Parties receive only information necessary to respond; sensitive personal data are minimized or redacted.

21.13 Interaction with Institutions & Funders

  • When concerns implicate research conduct, we may notify the relevant institution(s) or funder(s) and request an investigation report.
  • Editorial actions (e.g., expressions of concern) may proceed in parallel where public risk exists, independent of institutional timelines.

21.14 Outcomes & Remedies (Integrity)

  • Before publication: correction of files/figures, added disclosures, additional review, or rejection.
  • After publication: correction, addendum, editor’s note, expression of concern, retraction, or retraction and replacement, with permanent, open notices.

21.15 Non-Retaliation & Safety

  • Retaliation (threats, adverse professional actions) against reporters or participants is a serious violation and may result in bans from roles, notification to institutions, or legal steps where appropriate.

21.16 Bad-Faith or Abusive Reports

  • Reports made knowingly false, vexatious, or intended to harass may be closed without action and can trigger sanctions (loss of reviewer/editor privileges, platform suspension).

21.17 Accessibility and Language

  • Appeal/complaint forms are accessible (WCAG 2.2 AA). We provide alternative channels on request and accept submissions in plain English; short translations or summaries can be accommodated as capacity allows.

21.18 Record-Keeping and Transparency

  • We maintain an internal case log with timestamps, handlers, decisions, and rationales.
  • Aggregated, privacy-preserving annual statistics (volumes, response times, outcomes) may be published as part of our transparency reporting.
  • All policies carry version histories and last-updated dates.

21.19 Escalation Path

  • If a party believes the process was not followed, they may request an escalation review by a senior editorial leader unconnected to the case.
  • External bodies (e.g., institutional RIOs, national ombuds) may be engaged where jurisdiction applies; we cooperate within legal bounds.

21.20 Closure

  • Parties are informed of the outcome and the reasoning to the extent permitted by privacy and law.
  • When remedies include process changes or training, responsible owners and timelines are documented.

21.21 Templates (For Immediate Use)

  • Appeal Cover (Author):
  • Manuscript ID/DOI: …
  • Decision date: …
  • Specific points of error/misunderstanding: …
  • New evidence (files/links): …
  • Statement: “This appeal is made in good faith; to my knowledge, all information is accurate.”
  • Integrity Report (Whistleblower):
  • Article ID/DOI or preprint link: …
  • Concern type (e.g., image duplication in Fig. 2B; statistical anomaly in Table 1): …
  • Evidence (attachments/links): …
  • Risk (e.g., patient impact, biosafety): …
  • Relationship to the work (optional): …