Post-Publication Data & Method Audits

24.1 Purpose and Scope

  • This policy defines how we verify published work after publication to protect the scholarly record. It covers triggers, audit procedures, author responsibilities, confidentiality, outcomes, and records. Audits aim to clarify facts—not to punish—while ensuring rapid correction when needed.

24.2 Triggers for an Audit

An audit may be initiated by:

  • Reader, reviewer, or whistleblower reports (specific, evidence-based concerns).
  • Editorial screening signals (e.g., image duplication alerts, reference anomalies, statistical red flags).
  • Post-publication discourse (letters, comments, preprint critiques, replication failures).
  • Portfolio-wide sweeps (periodic checks for known risk patterns, e.g., paper-mill indicators).

24.3 Principles

  • Fair, proportionate, and documented.
  • Transparency to readers once a material issue is confirmed.
  • Due process for authors with clear timeframes.
  • Independence from commercial interests.

24.4 Scope of Audits

Audits may check:

  • Data integrity (raw data presence, consistency with figures/tables).
  • Image provenance (original files, processing steps, composite labeling).
  • Code and computational reproducibility (environment, scripts, outputs).
  • Methodological fidelity (consistency with protocol/registry/SAP).
  • Ethics and approvals (IRB/IACUC, permits, consent documentation).
  • COI/funding disclosures completeness.

24.5 Author Responsibilities

  • Timely cooperation: Acknowledge within 5 business days; provide requested materials by the specified date.
  • Materials to supply: Raw data (or controlled-access route), original images, analysis code and environment files, protocols/SAPs, approvals, data dictionaries.
  • Point of contact: Name a corresponding audit liaison who can coordinate materials and clarifications.
  • Retention: Maintain artifacts per Sections 5, 7, and 13; inability to produce promised materials may affect outcomes.

24.6 Confidentiality and Data Protection

  • Audit materials are handled under strict confidentiality and data-protection controls (see Section 15).
  • Human data: Use controlled-access transfers; share only the minimum necessary.
  • Materials are used solely for verification and not for unrelated research.

24.7 Levels of Audit (Escalating)

  • Level 0 — Clarification: Minor query resolved by author email; no public notice.
  • Level 1 — Targeted Check: Limited review of specific figure/table/code segment; may result in a brief correction.
  • Level 2 — Expanded Audit: Broader verification (multiple figures, datasets, or sections) with independent methods/statistical review.
  • Level 3 — Portfolio Review: When systemic issues are suspected (e.g., guest-edited collection or paper-mill pattern), we audit related articles.

24.8 Independent Expertise

  • We may engage external experts (statistics, imaging forensics, domain specialists) bound by confidentiality and COI declarations.
  • For clinical or biosafety concerns, we may consult institutional or regulatory bodies in parallel.

24.9 Timelines

  • Acknowledgment to reporter: within 5 business days (when contactable).
  • Initial author request: within 10 business days of trigger.
  • Author response window: typically 14–30 days, proportionate to scope; extensions considered with justification.
  • Status updates: provided to authors and, when appropriate, to the reporter at key milestones.

24.10 Decision Framework & Outcomes

  • No action: Concerns unfounded or clarified; internal note recorded.
  • Correction/Addendum: Minor errors that do not alter conclusions (e.g., mislabeled axis, missing unit, code path note).
  • Replacement Figures/Data Note: Replace an image/plot with correct version; provenance disclosed.
  • Expression of Concern (EoC): Public notice while investigation continues for substantial, unresolved doubts.
  • Retraction / Retraction & Replacement: When findings are unreliable or misconduct/honest error invalidates conclusions (Section 10).
  • Sanctions: For non-cooperation or confirmed misconduct, actions per Section 10 may apply.

24.11 Public Communication

  • Where the record is affected, we publish a clear, neutral notice linked bidirectionally to the article describing the issue, verification steps, and outcome.
  • We avoid unnecessary disclosure of personal data or speculative statements.

24.12 Audit Trails & Preservation

  • Maintain an internal audit file (requests, evidence, analyses, decisions).
  • Updated files (e.g., corrected figures) replace prior versions while preserving version history (Section 13).
  • Indexers (e.g., Crossref) receive updated metadata for corrections/EoCs/retractions.

24.13 Replication Packages & Post-Audit Artifacts

  • When feasible, publish improved replication packages (clean code, documented data transforms, environment files) as supplementary material or in repositories with DOIs.
  • If access must remain controlled (privacy/safety), publish metadata and an access route.

24.14 Appeals of Audit Outcomes

  • Authors may submit a reasoned appeal with new evidence or procedural concerns within a defined window (e.g., 30 days).
  • Appeals are handled by an independent editor/committee not involved in the initial review (see Section 21).

24.15 Education and Prevention

  • Aggregate, anonymized insights from audits inform author guidance, reviewer training, and automated checks (Sections 6–9).
  • We periodically share a portfolio integrity report (privacy-preserving) highlighting common issues and fixes.

24.16 Non-Cooperation

  • Failure to engage or to provide promised materials without compelling justification may itself prompt editorial action (EoC, correction, or retraction) to protect readers.

24.17 Coordination with Institutions & Funders

  • Where institutional investigation is necessary, we coordinate timelines while retaining the ability to issue interim public notices to mitigate risk.

24.18 Scope Limits

  • Audits assess verifiability and consistency with stated methods; they are not full re-analyses unless needed to resolve material concerns.
  • We prioritize issues that could change conclusions, safety, or policy relevance.

24.19 Record Keeping & Metrics

  • Log counts, turnaround times, and outcomes; review periodically for process improvement and resource planning.
  • Maintain versioned policy with last-updated dates on this page.